Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Tiny Docker Operating Systems (docker.com)
109 points by alexcasalboni on March 11, 2015 | hide | past | favorite | 20 comments


Not mentioned in this blog post is CoreOS, one of the leading operating systems in this category.

I'm happy to see the variety of operating systems coming out lately.


The very first link in the article leads to the previous post [1] that does mention CoreOS.

[1] http://blog.docker.com/2015/02/the-new-minimalist-operating-...


CoreOS is not huge but is also much bigger than these systems. The virtualbox image for example is 113MB compressed and 358MB uncompressed.

http://alpha.release.core-os.net/amd64-usr/current/coreos_pr...


I think that's only because they don't see CoreOS as "minimal" in the same sense as Rancher and boot2docker.


CoreOS isn't intended to be the base image of a docker container, it's meant to be the host for docker containers.


Boot2Docker and RancherOS are also meant to be hosts for containers.


OT: I really hate group blogs (more than one author) with byline at the bottom after the content.

The subject of the first sentence in the post is "I". I've no idea who this "I" is unless scrolling to the bottom.

Please place the byline below the title.


How do you feel about The Economist's publication style?


The Economist works hard at having a house writing style and a house viewpoint. You will never see "I" in an unsigned Economist article.


No, but you might see "This author..." sometimes instead. Economist does pretty well, but personality still seems into some of the non-editorials.


Not mentioned: https://github.com/ibuildthecloud/only-docker

(though it's more of an experiment than an OS)


I think that's what RacherOS does as well, which is interesting as they're claiming it's production ready! Only Docker seems neat, I'm loving all of these experiments.


The same guy (Darren aka "ibuildthecloud") is behind both projects. He is very prolific.


I'm not quite up to speed here, but aren't these simple linux user lands, running on a normal Kernel, and not actually real OSes that provide a new set of APIs to interact with the system?

I see all these "DockerOS", "RancherOS", "CoreOS" things and at the end it is just a kernel and a set of programs that take over the init process in a certain way.


Careful or you may fall into the 'What is an OS' discussion. :)

They are all kernels and suites of tools, namely Docker and usually Busybox. The primary objective in all cases is to have a minimal OS host for Docker containers so they can drop the normal suite of tools.


Seems like guys that can cram chess programs into less than 1k would be great for this type of development.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9151552


Text-only for those who can't load the page.

http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:eboGGnF...


[flagged]


> Seems like they're trying to puff themselves up again; wonder what stupid thing they are up to now.

There are two rules about HN comments: be civil, and be substantive. This comment is uncivil and unsubstantive.

All: when you see a comment that violates the HN guidelines this badly, please flag it by clicking on its timestamp ("x hours ago") to go to its page, then clicking "flag".


You forgot to add the following

> Caution Troll Crossway.

1) That was a simple question; it was a leading question asking the direction Docker is taking now. That maybe disrespectful to a few people in Docker; but I think it's a good question as a user who uses docker.

2) Your negative comment was unwarranted and unnecessary.

I will flag your comment but I am sure people will view me as the antagonist instead of someone who was attacked for no reason.


Oh that's right, I can't flag because I don't have enough Karma.

> Someday there will be someone who launches a replacement for HN that shows less Elitism.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: