Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

To be fair: that's a little spun. He certainly didn't refuse to share it.

To extend the metaphor past the breaking point: he offered it only to those willing to bake pies for others. But the partygoers just wanted dessert, they didn't want to be stuck baking for others. If you like pies and think people should bake them for each other, that's hardly a crisis.

But you're absolutely right that this is about social issues, and not pies or licenses at all. What people are really angry about isn't the pie they have to bake, it's that Zed showed up with a blueberry pie, when everyone had agreed that they would eat only apple pies. And even though that blueberry pie looks good, it marks Zed as one of the enemy. So he must be shunned.



By sharing, I meant that he is not sharing his code in such a way that they can feed it back in their own BSD...pies.


No no no . . . it's more like the others didn't want to be required to demand that other people bake pies for them.

"Look, when I bake a pie and give it away to other people, I just want other people to have the pie and be happy. Why the fuck do I have to promise to demand that other people bake pies for me if I use your recipe when I bake pies for them?"




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: