Call bullshit? Please. Just say you disagree or something. Bullshit implies that I'm intentionally trying to feed you false information. And you've misunderstood. The line of reasoning you quote is about how C++ introduced new and delete to circumvent the follies of malloc and free. But the upshot was that even new and delete had pitfalls that developers fell prey to, so then came tr1's shared_ptr, followed by unique_ptr, which then necessitated, make_shared, etc. Where did I say this is a call to go back to C? Where did you learn how to read?