Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> what sense does it make to vote for an unpatriotic politician?

I really dislike the concept of "patriotism". What does it even mean? I think you'll get different answers if you get different people.

If people think that being critical of the US makes someone "unpatriotic", then that's their problem. If that makes a critical politician less electable, so be it. The alternative -- politicians censoring themselves and pretending everything is amazing -- is much worse.

And I'm not sure where the right is coming from anyway. The whole concept of MAGA is that the US kinda sucks right now and Trump is the savior who will fix it. If anyone has been critical of the US, it's been Trump and the MAGA crowd. But of course hypocrisy is never a problem for the right.



I think it mostly about perspective of history.

For those that were attracted to it, Trump presented the idea that America and it's people are good at good at their core, and this can be brought back.

Those same people view rhetoric from the other side as saying America is and was fundamentally evil and corrupt. They take this personally as a condemnation of them and their family.


He only presented that idea to a certain slice of Americans. If you were a Haitian American, you probably ate cats and dogs according to him.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: