I’m not sure this is generally true, and you’re ignoring a lot of context around the specific situation of GCC.
Just to make a point: I could throw out SQLite as a project that bans open contributions and is wildly successful.
Also, as others pointed out, Linux is technically open contribution bazaar style by 2000s standards. But if you look at how to actually get involved, there’s way more friction compared to the average GitHub project.
I actually think GCC falls into the same category. Even though it’s technically open contribution these days, it’s not exactly a free for all where any AI agent can open a GitHub pull request and get it reviewed.
You have to mail patches to a mailing list and follow a bunch of super specific and arcane rules set by the grey beards.
Just to make a point: I could throw out SQLite as a project that bans open contributions and is wildly successful.
Also, as others pointed out, Linux is technically open contribution bazaar style by 2000s standards. But if you look at how to actually get involved, there’s way more friction compared to the average GitHub project.
I actually think GCC falls into the same category. Even though it’s technically open contribution these days, it’s not exactly a free for all where any AI agent can open a GitHub pull request and get it reviewed.
You have to mail patches to a mailing list and follow a bunch of super specific and arcane rules set by the grey beards.