Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Mathematics is the art of highlighting the necessary consequences of a situation. That's all.

The situations that we mathematicians mostly consider are axiomatic constructs, because it's easier to then unambiguously establish necessity.

That this art, its methods, techniques and tools, happens to be so useful to other sciences (and in fact most of human knowledge) is an interesting phenomenon...



Mathematics is also used for purely abstract entertainment.

Also, your definition applies to physics as well.


> Also, your definition applies to physics as well.

Um.... I think that it looks like that a lot of what maths does is shared with physics, but I think (I could be wrong) that it's mostly because physics has adopted the language of mathematics.

That having been said, there is an aspect where they are definitively different. Physics is motivated by the understanding of the physical world. For instance a physics theory gets dropped when we discover that we mis-observed whatever it was meant to explain. This doesn't happen in maths. The theories in maths (here defined as axiomatic structures) do not need to align with the natural world and get studied for other reasons than because they would increase the understanding of the natural world. Such understanding may eventually happen, but was not the motivation factor.

What do you think ? :)


In my opinion, math is:

- an extension of pure logic

- not a science (since it cannot be falsified)

- only indirectly concerned with observations (because we don't know the universe)

- used to predict, but also to reason about the past (big bang theories)

- a tool

- a game (puzzle)


Maths is logic with axioms that are intuitively true.

Physics is maths with the addition of experimentally verified axioms.

Chemistry is Physics with the addition of heuristics that explain phenomena which are too complex to express using casual logic.

Every step after chemistry just add additional heuristics.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: